Journal Article

Facial bone fragmentation in blind cavefish arises through two unusual ossification processes

Powers, A.K., Kaplan, S.A., Boggs, T.E. and Gross, J.

Record Number:
3938
Year:
2018
Journal:
Scientific Reports
Pages:
1-10
Volume:
8:7015
Abstract:
The precise mechanisms underlying cranial bone development, evolution and patterning remain incompletely characterised. This poses a challenge to understanding the etiologies of craniofacial malformations evolving in nature. Capitalising on natural variation, “evolutionary model systems” provide unique opportunities to identify underlying causes of aberrant phenotypes as a complement to studies in traditional systems. Mexican blind cavefish are a prime evolutionary model for cranial disorders since they frequently exhibit extreme alterations to the skull and lateral asymmetries. These aberrations occur in stark contrast to the normal cranial architectures of closely related surfacedwelling fish, providing a powerful comparative paradigm for understanding cranial bone formation. Using a longitudinal and in vivo analytical approach, we discovered two unusual ossification processes in cavefish that underlie the development of ‘fragmented’ and asymmetric cranial bones. The first mechanism involves the sporadic appearance of independent bony elements that fail to fuse together later in development. The second mechanism involves the “carving” of channels in the mature bone, a novel form of post-ossification remodeling. In the extreme cave environment, these novel mechanisms may have evolved to augment sensory input, and may indirectly result in a trade-off between sensory expansion and cranial bone development.
Times Cited:
1
Related Records:
Hubbs, C.L. and Innes, W.T. (1936)Bridges, W. (1940)Gresser, E. B. and Breder, C. M. (1940)Breder, C. M. and Gresser, E. B. (1941)Breder, C. M. and Gresser, E. B. (1941)Breder, C. M. and Gresser, E. B. (1941)Breder, C. M. (1942)Osorio Tafall, B. F. (1943)Breder, C. M. (1943)Breder, C. M. (1943)Breder, C. M. (1944)Alvarez, J. (1946)Breder, C. M. and Rasquin, P. (1947)Breder, C. M. and Rasquin, P. (1947)Alvarez, J. (1947)Schlagel, S. R. and Breder, C. M. (1947)Rasquin, P. (1949)Luling, K. H. (1953)Luling, K. H. (1953)Luling, K. H. (1953)Luling, K. H. (1954)Luling, K. H. (1954)Stefanelli, A. (1954)Thines, G. (1954)Stefanelli, A. (1954)Rasquin, P. and Rosenbloom, L. (1954)Luling, K. H. (1955)Luling, K. H. (1955)Sadoglu, P. (1956)Sadoglu, P. (1957)Sadoglu, P. (1957)Thines, G. and Kahling, J. (1957)Grobbel, G. and Hahn, G. (1958)Cahn, P. H. (1958)Kahling, J. (1961)Luling, K. H. (1962)Burgers, A. C. J., Bennink, P. J. H. and van Oordt, G. J. (1963)Franck, A. (1964)Boucquey, C., Thines, G. and Van Der Borght, C. (1965)Thines, G., Wolff-Van Ermengem, F., Boucquey, C. and Soffie, M. (1965)Carmignani, M. P. A. (1966)Cavicchioli, G. and Guarnieri, P. (1966)Peters, N. and Peters, G. (1966)Thines, G., Soffie, M. and Vandenbussche, E. (1966)Reed, M. (1966)Walters, V. and Liu, R. K. (1967)Sadoglu, P. (1967)Schemmel, C. (1967)Pfeiffer, W. (1967)Pfeiffer, W. (1967)Popper, A. N. and Tavolga, W. N. (1967)Carmignani, M. P. A. (1968)Wilkens, H. (1968)Mattheij, J. A. (1968)Mattheij, J. A. (1968)Weiss, B. A. (1969)Sadoglu, P. and McKee, A. (1969)Mattheij, J. A. (1969)Mattheij, J. A. and Sprangers, J. A. P. (1969)Gertychowa, R. (1970)Gertychowa, R. (1970)Weiss, B. and Martini, J. (1970)Whitt, G. S. and Maeda, F. S. (1970)Wilkens, H. (1970)Wilkens, H. (1970)Wilkens, H. (1970)Mattheij, J. A. (1970)Mattheij, J. A. (1970)Popper, A. N. (1970)Zaccone, G. (1971)Gertychowa, R. (1971)Wiley, S. and Mitchell, R. W. (1971)Wiley, S. and Mitchell, R. W. (1971)Wilkens, H. (1971)Popper, A. N. (1971)Zaccone, G. (1972)Avise, J. C. and Selander, R. K. (1972)Wilkens, H. (1972)Wilkens, H. (1972)Wilkens, H. (1972)Thines, G. and Wissocq, N. (1972)Wilkens, H. and Burns, R. J. (1972)Voneida, T. J. (1973)Zeitlin, S. M. (1973)Zeitlin, S. M. and McDevitt, D. S. (1973)Mitchell, R. W. (1973)Schemmel, C. (1973)Durand, J. P. (1973)Yasuda, K. (1973)Thines, G. and LeGrain, J. M. (1973)Chakraborty, R. and Nei, M. (1974)Schemmel, C. (1974)Schemmel, C. (1974)Sligar, C. (1974)Omura, Y. (1975)Sadoglu, P. (1975)Peters, N., Scholl, A. and Wilkens, H. (1975)Voneida, T. J. and Sligar, C. (1976)Herwig, H. J. (1976)Herwig, H. J. (1976)Wilkens, H. (1976)Durand, J. P. (1976)Sligar, C. and Voneida, T. J. (1976)Erckens, W. and Weber, F. (1976)Zaccone, G. (1977)Mitchell, R. W., Russell, W. H. and Elliott, W. R. (1977)Wilkens, H. (1977)Kirby, R. F., Thompson, K. W. and Hubbs, C. (1977)Yew, D. T. and Yoshihara, H. M. (1977)Durand, J. P. (1978)Thines, G. and Weyers, M. (1978)Wilkens, H., Peters, H. and Schemmel, C. (1979)Woodhead, A. D. and Achey, P. M. (1979)Sadoglu, P. (1979)Durand, J. P. (1979)Weissert, R. (1980)Schemmel, C. (1980)Wilkens, H. (1980)Wilkens, H. (1980)Quinn, T. P. (1980)Weissert, R. and Campenhausen, C. (1981)Campenhausen, C., Riess, I. and Weissert, R. (1981)Herwig, H. J. (1981)Reddell, J. R. (1981)Rose, F. L. and Mitchell, R. W. (1982)Tabata, M. (1982)Jankowska, M. and Thines, G. (1982)Erckens, W. and Martin, W. (1982)Erckens, W. and Martin, W. (1982)Lamprecht, G. and Weber, F. (1982)Romero, A. (1983)Zilles, K., Tillmann, B. and Bennemann, R. (1983)Parzefall, J. (1983)Voneida, T. J. and Fish, S. E. (1984)Romero, A. (1984)Romero, A. (1984)Schuppa, M. (1984)Wilkens, H. (1984)Burchards, H., Dolle, A. and Parzefall, J. (1985)Romero, A. (1985)Teyke, T. (1985)Wilkens, H. (1985)Lamprecht, G. and Weber, F. (1985)Romero, A. (1986)Hassan, E. S. (1986)Parzefall, J. (1986)De Fraipont, M. (1986)Huppop, K. (1986)Fraipont, M. (1986)De Fraipont, M. and Thines, G. (1986)De Fraipont, M. and Thines, G. (1986)Wilkens, H. (1986)Wilkens, H. and Huppop, K. (1986)Huppop, K. (1987)De Fraipont, M. (1987)De Fraipont, M. (1987)Wilkens, H. (1987)Fricke, D. (1988)Huppop, K. (1988)De Fraipont, M. (1988)Teyke, T. (1988)Wilkens, H. (1988)Langecker, T. G. (1989)Fricke, D. and Parzefall, J. (1989)Fack, H. and Wilkens, H. (1989)Hassan, E. S. (1989)Huppop, K. (1989)Teyke, T. (1989)Langecker, T. G. (1990)Abdel-Latif, H., Hassan, E. S. and von Campenhausen, C. (1990)Parzefall, J. and Fricke, D. (1990)Peters, N., Schmidt, W. and Fricke, D. (1990)Teyke, T. (1990)Klimpel, B. and Parzefall, J. (1990)Yokoyama, R. and Yokoyama, S. (1990)Yokoyama, R and Yokoyama, S (1990)Riedel, G. and Krug, L. (1991)Langecker, T. G., Wilkens, H. and Junge, P. (1991)Campenhausen, C. (1991)Parzefall, J. and Fricke, D. (1991)Huppop, K. and Wilkens, H. (1991)Huppop, K. (1991)Wilkens, H. and Meyer, M. (1992)Langecker, T. G. and Longley, G. (1992)Hassan, E. S., Abdel-Latif, H. and Biebricher, R. (1992)Parzefall, J. (1992)Parzefall, J. (1992)De Fraipont, M. (1992)Wilkens, H. (1992)Lamprecht, G. and Weber, F. (1992)Langecker, T. G. (1993)Langecker, T. G., Schmale, H. and Wilkens, H. (1993)Langecker, T. G., Schmale, H. and Wilkens, H. (1993)Hoffman, S. and Hausberg, C. (1993)Parzefall, J. (1993)Peters, N., Schacht, V., Schmidt, W. and Wilkens, H. (1993)Teyke, T. and Schaerer, S. (1994)Borowsky, R. (1994)Langecker, T. G., Neumann, B., Hausberg, C. and Parzefall, J. (1995)Langecker, T. G., Wilkens, H. and Schmale, H. (1995)Yokoyama, S., Meany, A., Wilkens, H. and Yokoyama, R. (1995)Borowsky, R. (1996)Riedel, G. and Krug, L. (1997)Behrens, M., Langecker, T.G., Wilkens, H. and Schmale, H. (1997)Borowsky, R. and Espinasa, L. (1997)Riedel, G. (1997)Contreras-Balderas, S. and Lozano-Vilano, M.D.L. (1998)Behrens, M, Wilkens, H and Schmale, H (1998)Jeffery, WR and Martasian, DP (1998)Wilkens, H. (1998)Baker, CF and Montgomery, J (1999)Kullander, S. O. (1999)Ford, D.C. (2000)Yamamoto, Y. and Jeffery, W. R. (2000)Jeffery, W. R., Strickler, A.G., Guiney, S., Heyser, D.G. and Tomarev, S.I. (2000)Espinasa, L. and Borowsky, R. (2000)Montgomery, J.C., Coombs, S. and Baker, C.F. (2001)Strickler, A.G., Yamamoto, Y. and Jeffery, W. R. (2001)Jeffery, W. R. (2001)Boudriot, F and Reutter, K (2001)Espinasa, L. and Borowsky, R. (2001)Krejca, J. (2002)Strickler, AG, Famuditimi, K and Jeffery, WR (2002)Berg, A. and Watson, G.M. (2002)Dowling, TE, Martasian, DP and Jeffery, WR (2002)Romero, A., Jeffery, W.R. and Yamamoto, Y. (2002)Borowsky, RL and Wilkens, H (2002)Wilkens, H. and Strecker, U. (2003)Porter, M.L. and Crandall, K.A. (2003)Contreras-Balderas, S, Almada-Villela, P, Lozano-Vilano, M de L and Garcia-Ramirez, ME (2003)Sarma, SSS, Lopez-Romulo, A and Nandini, S (2003)Strecker, U. (2003)Strecker, U., Bernatchez, L. and Wilkens, H. (2003)McCauley, DW, Hixon, E and Jeffery, WR (2004)Protas ME, Hersey C, Kochanek D, Zhou Y, Wilkens H, Jeffery WR, Zon LI, Borowsky R, Tabin CJ. (2006)Protas, M., Conrad, M., Gross, J.B., Tabin, C. and Borowsky, R.L. (2007)Protas, M, Tabansky, I, Conrad, M, Gross, JB, Vidal, O, Tabin, C and Borowsky, RL (2008)Gross, J.B., Protas, M., Conrad, M., Scheid, P.E., Vidal, O., Jeffery, W.R., Tabin, C. and others (2008)Salin, K, Voituron, Y, Colson, C and Hervant, F (2008)Jeffery, WR (2009)Kowalko, J, Gross, JB, Protas, M, Borowsky, RL and Tabin, C (2009)Salin, K., Voituron, Y., Mourin, J. and Hervant, F. (2010)Esquivel-Bobadilla, S (2011)Yamamoto, Y. and Jeffery, W.R. (2011)Kish, P.E., Bohnsack, B.L., Gallina, D., Kasprick, D.S. and Kahana, A. (2011)Kowalko, J, Rohner, N, Borowsky, RL and Tabin, C (2011)Salin, K, Voituron, Y, Mourin, J and Hervant, F (2011)Bradic, M, Beerli, P and Borowsky, RL (2011)Idda, M.L., Bertolucci, C., Vallone, D., Gothilf, Y., Sánchez-Vázquez, F.J. and Foulkes N.S. (2012)Wilkens, H. (2012)Trontelj, P. (2012)Jeffery, W.R. (2012)Dufton, M, Hall, BK and Franz-Odendaal, T. (2012)Protas, M. and Jeffery, W. R. (2012)Gross, J.B. (2012)Hervant, F. (2012)Bradic, M., Beerli, P., Garcia-de Leon, F. J., Esquivel-Bobadilla, S. and Borowsky, R. L. (2012)Pazza, R (2013)Atukorala, A. D. S., Hammer, C., Dufton, M. and Franz-Odendaal, T. A. (2013)Kowalko, J.E., Rohner, N., Rompani, S.B., Peterson, B.K., Linden, T.A., Yoshizawa, M., Kay, E.H., Weber, J., Hoekstra, H.E., Jeffery, W.R., Borowsky, R. and Tabin, C.J. (2013)Beale, A., Guibal, C., Tamai, T. K., Klotz, L., Cowen, S., Peyric, E., Reynoso, V. H., Yamamoto, Y. and Whitmore, D. (2013)Rohner, N., Jarosz, D.F., Kowalko, J.E., Yoshizawa, M., Jeffery, W.R., Borowsky, R.L., Lindquist, S. and Tabin, C.J. (2013)Beale, A. (2013)Rohner, N (2013)Kowalko, J., Rohner, N., Linden, T.A., Rompani S.B., Warren, W.C., Borowsky, R., Tabin, C.J., Jeffery, W.R. and Yoshizawa M. (2013)Gross, J.B., Furterer, A., Carlson, B.M. and Stahl, B.A. (2013)Elliott, William R. (2013)Stahl, B. A. and Gross, J. B. (2013)Stahl, AL (2013)Bradic, M., Teotonio, H. and Borowsky, R. L. (2013)Bibliowicz, J., Alie, A., Espinasa, L., Yoshizawa, M., Blin, M., Hinaux, H., Legendre, L., Pere, S. and Retaux, S. (2013)Gross, J.B., Krutzler, A.J. and Carlson, B.M. (2014)Moran, D., Softley, R. and Warrant, E.J. (2014)Espinasa, L., Bartolo, N.D. and Newkirk, C.E. (2014)Atukorallaya, D. and Franz-Odendaal, T. (2014)McGaugh, S.E., Gross, J.B., Aken, B., Blin, M., Borowsky, R., Chalopin, D., Hinaux, H., Jeffery, W.R., Keene, A., Ma, L., Minx, P., Murphy, D., O'Quin, K.E., Retaux, S., Rohner, N., Searl, S.M., Stahl, B.A., Tabin, C., Volff, J.N., Yoshizawa M, Warren WC. (2014)Atukorala, A. D. S. and Franz-Odendaal, T. A. (2014)Elliott, W.R. (2014)Stemmer, M., Schuhmacher, L.-N., Foulkes, N.S., Bertolucci, C. and Wittbrodt, J. (2015)Silva, D. M. Z. A., Utsunomia, R., Pansonato-Alves, J.C., Oliveira, C. and Foresti, F. (2015)Carlson, B.M., Onusko, S.W. and Gross, J.B. (2015)Moran, D., Softley, R. and Warrant, E.J. (2015)Hinaux, H., Blin, M., Fumey, J., Legendre, L., Heuze, A., Casane, D. and Retaux, S. (2015)Fumey, J. (2015)McGaugh, S. E. (2015)Dufton, Megan and Franz-Odendaal, Tamara A. (2015)Aspiras, A.C., Rohner, N., Martineau, B., Borowsky, R.L. and Tabin, C.J. (2015)Stahl, Bethany A. and Gross, Joshua B. (2015)Stahl, B. A., Ma, L and Gross, J. B. (2015)Caballero-Hernandez, O., Hernandez-Patricio, M., Sigala-Regalado, I., Morales-Malacara, J. B. and Miranda-Anaya, M. (2015)Yoshizawa, Masato, Robinson, Beatriz G., Duboue, Erik R., Masek, Pavel, Jaggard, James B., O'Quin, Kelly E., Borowsky, Richard L., Jeffery, William R. and Keene, Alex C. (2015)Bradic, M, Rohner, N, Tabin, C and Borowsky, R. (2015)Jaggard, J. B. (2015)Rohner, N (2015)Devos, Lucie, Alie, A. and Retaux, S (2015)Foulkes, N. S., Whitmore, D., Vallone, D and Bertolucci, C. (2016)Keene, A.C., Yoshizawa, M. and McGaugh, S.E. (2016)Casane, D. and Retaux, S. (2016)Carlson, B.M. and Gross, J.B. (2016)Beale, A., Whitmore, D. and Moran, D. (2016)O'Quin, Kelly and McGaugh, Suzanne E. (2016)Atukorala, A. D. S. and Franz-Odendaal, Tamara A. (2016)Beale, A. D. and Whitmore, D. (2016)Gross, J.B., Stahl, B.A., Powers, A.K. and Carlson, B.M. (2016)Schmitter-Soto, JJ (2016)Rohner, Nicolas (2016)Yoshizawa, M., Settle, A., Macaspac, C., Fernandes, V. Yoshida, M. and Keene, A. (2016)Aspiras, A., Tabin, C. and Rohner, N. (2016)Retaux, S., Alie, A., Blin, M., Devos, L., Elipot, Y. and Hinaux, H. (2016)Hinaux, H, Recher, G, Alie, A., Legendre, L, Blin, M. and Retaux, S (2017)Torres-Paz, J (2017)Wilkens, H. and Strecker, U. (2017)Fumey J, Hinaux H, Noirot C, Thermes C, Re´ taux S, Casane D. (2017)Lyon, A., Powers, A. K., Gross, J. B. and O'Quin, K. E. (2017)Gross, J. B. (2017)Kaplan, S.A., Powers, A.K. and Gross, J.B. (2017)Jaggard, J. B., Robinson, B. G., Stahl, B, Oh, I, Masek, P, Yoshizawa, M and Keene, A. (2017)Schmitter-Soto, JJ (2017)Stahl, B (2017)Stahl, B.A. and Gross, J.B. (2017)Jaggard, J. B. (2017)Yoshizawa, M (2017)Krishnan, J and Rohner, N (2017)Alvarado, C.G. (2017)Rohner, N. (2018)Garita-Alvarado, C.A., Barluenga, M. and Ornelas-García, C.P. (2018)Alie, A., Devos, L., Torres-Paz, J., Prunier, L., Boulet, F., Blin, M., Elipot, Y. and Retaux, S. (2018)Pazza, R., Dergam, J.A. and Kavalco, K.F. (2018)Elliott, W.R. (2018)Devitsina, G.V. and Golovkina, T.V. (2018)Kopp, J., Avasthi, S. and Espinasa, L. (2018)Torres-Paz,J., Hyacinthe, C., Pierre, C., Retaux, S. (2018)Kling, J. (2018)Ojha, A. and Watve, M. (2018)Gore, A., Jeffery, W., Retaux, S. and Rohner, N. (2018)Chin, J.S.R., Gassant, C.E., Amaral, P.M., Lloyd, E., Stahl, B.A., Jaggard, J.B., Keene, A.C. and Duboue, E.R. (2018)Gore, A.V., Rohner, N., Rétaux, S. and Jeffery, W.R. (2018)Fumey, J., Hinaux, H., Noirot, C., Thermes, C., Rétaux, S. and Casane, D. (2018)Ma, L., Strickler, A.G., Parkhurst, A., Yoshizawa, M., Shi, J. and Jeffery, W.R. (2018)Stern, D.B and Crandall, K.A. (2018)Ren, X.Y., Hamilton, N., Müller, F. and Yamamoto, Y. (2018)Carlson, B.M., Klingler, I.B., Meyer, B.J. and Gross, J.B. (2018)Xiong, S., Krishnan, J., Peuß, F. and Rohner, N. (2018)Klaassen, H., Wang, Y., Adamski, K., Rohner, N. and Kowalko, J.E. (2018)Rohner, N. (2018)Gross, J.B., Weagley, J., Stahl, B.A., Ma, L., Espinasa, L. and McGaugh, S.E. (2018)Devi, A., Atukorala, S. and Franz-Odendaal, T.A. (2018)Frøland Steindal, I.V., Beale, A.D., Yamamoto, Y. and Whitmore, D. (2018)Retaux, S. (2018)Blin, M., Tine, E., Meister, L., Elipot, Y., Bibliowicz, J., Espinasa, L. and Rétaux, S. (2018)Ornelas-García, P,. Pajares, S., Sosa-Jiménez, V.M., Rétaux, S. and Miranda-Gamboa, R.A. (2018)Powers, A.K., Kaplan, S.A., Boggs, T.E. and Gross, J. (2018)Carlson, B.M. and Gross, J.B. (2018)Espinasa, L. (2018)Sears, C.R. and Gross, J.B. (2018)Espinasa, L., Legendre, L., Fumey, J., Blin, M., Rétaux, S. and Espinasa, M. (2018)Stah, B.A., Sears, C.R., Ma, L., Perkins, M. and Gross, J.B. (2018)Mirande, J.M. (2018)Powers, A.K., Boggs, T.E. and Gross, J.B. (2018)Borowsky, R. (2018)Jaggard, J.B., Stahl, B.A., Lloyd, E., Prober, D.A., Duboue, E.R. and Keene, A.C. (2018)Tabin, J.A., Aspiras, A., Martineau, B., Riddle, M., Kowalko, J. Borowsky, R. Rohner, N. and Tabin, C.J. (2018)Borowsky, R., Luk, A., He, X.J. and Kim, R.S. (2018)Yoshizawa, M., Settle, A., Hermosura, M.C., Tuttle, L.J., Cetraro, N., Passow, C.N. and McGaugh, S.E. (2018)Riddle, M.R., Aspiras, A.C., Gaudenz, K., Peuß, R., Sung, J.Y., Martineau, B., Peavey, M., Box, A.C., Tabin, J.A., McGaugh, S., Borowsky, R., Tabin, C.J. and Rohner, N. (2018)Fernandes, V.F.L., Macaspac, C., Lu, L. and Yoshizawa, M. (2018)